Phyllachora maydis, the causal agent of tar spot of maize: addition to the EPPO Alert List
Why: Tar spot is a foliar fungal disease of maize (Zea mays) which is emerging in the USA and causing economic damage to maize crops. There is some debate about the causal agents of this disease. In Latin America where the disease is thought to be endemic, tar spot has been associated with several fungal species: Phyllachora maydis, Monographella maydis and Coniothyrium phyllachorae. In Mexico, it was reported that on maize plants, infections by Phyllachora maydis were then followed by Monographella maydis infections, and that the latter was responsible for the appearance of ‘fisheye’ lesions on the foliage. However, in the USA, where this type of foliar symptoms is also observed, only P. maydis has been detected in maize plants affected by tar spot. Considering the importance of maize and the absence of tar spot in the EPPO region, as well as the fact that the disease is causing economic damage in its introduced range, the EPPO Secretariat considered that Phyllachora maydis could usefully be added to the EPPO Alert List.
Where: P. maydis was initially described in 1904 in Mexico and occurs in several countries of Central and South America. In 2015, the fungus was first recorded in the USA, in Illinois and Indiana (EPPO RS 2016/016), and then spread to other states.
EPPO region: Absent.
North America: Mexico, USA (Florida, Illinois, Indiana, Iowa, Michigan, Minnesota, Missouri, Ohio, Wisconsin).
Central America and the Caribbean: Costa Rica, Cuba, Dominican Republic, El Salvador, Guatemala, Haiti, Honduras, Nicaragua, Panama, Puerto Rico, Trinidad and Tobago, Virgin Islands (US).
South America: Bolivia, Colombia, Ecuador, Peru, Venezuela.
On which plants: maize (Zea mays) is the only known host.
Damage: Initial symptoms of tar spot are small chlorotic lesions, followed by the development of brown to black stromata (0.5-2.5 mm diameter – fruiting bodies of P. maydis) scattered across the upper and lower leaf surfaces. In severe cases, these symptoms can also be observed on leaf sheaths and husks. Stromata are sometimes surrounded by brown, elliptical, necrotic halos (fisheye lesions). In severe cases, these lesions coalesce, causing extensive necrosis and leaf blight leading to premature senescence and death of maize plants. Tar spot can reduce maize grain yield, quality of silage, stover and husks. Yield loss has been attributed to reduced ear weight, poor kernel filling, loose kernels, and vivipary (germination of seeds before they reach maturity). In Latin America, grain losses ranging from 10 to 45% have been observed in case of severe epidemics. In the USA, up to 30% grain yield losses have been reported.
Dissemination: The disease cycle is not fully understood. P. maydis overwinters (as ascospores and conidia in stromata) on decaying maize leaves or residues remaining in the fields. It is thought that infected plant residues are the source of primary inoculum. Ascospores are released from stromata and are dispersed by wind and rain during periods of moderate temperature (16 to 23°C), leaf wetness duration of more than 7 h per night, and relative humidity of more than 75%. Ascospores then infect nearby maize plants and this cycle is repeated multiple times during the growing season. It has been shown that ascospores could be dispersed as far as 31 m from the inoculum sources. S. maydis is not known to be seedborne, and it is not known how P. maydis reached the USA. It is suggested that infected leaf/husk residues contaminating traded grains could be a pathway to spread the disease over long distances.
Pathways: contaminating plant residues associated with maize seeds? soil?
Possible risks: Maize is widely grown in the EPPO region and is an economically important crop. Tar spot is an emerging disease of maize in the USA and is considered there as a threat to maize production. Control strategies against the disease are currently limited and further research is needed. It is estimated that control will probably have to rely on good cultural practices (e.g. rotation, removal of infected plant residues), biological control or appropriate fungicide treatments and use of tolerant/resistant maize varieties (none are available at present). As there is a general lack of information about tar spot and P. maydis, the possible risks for the EPPO region are difficult to assess. In particular, the pathways for introducing the fungus into new areas would need to be better understood. However, the recent emergence in the USA and the economic damage observed advocate for caution, and the EPPO Secretariat felt that the attention of NPPOs should be attracted to this maize disease.
CABI. Invasive Species Compendium. Phyllachora maydis (black spot of maize). https://www.cabi.org/isc/datasheet/40876 (last accessed 2021-10).
Chalkley D (2021) Systematic Mycology and Microbiology Laboratory, ARS, USDA. Invasive Fungi. Tar spot of corn-Phyllachora maydis. https://nt.ars-grin.gov/taxadescriptions/factsheets/index.cfm?thisapp=Phyllachoramaydis (last accessed 2021-10).
Dalla Lana F, Plewa DE, Phillippi ES, Garzonio D, Hesterman R, Kleczewski NM, Paul PA (2019) First report of tar spot of maize (Zea mays), caused by Phyllachora maydis, in Ohio. Plant Disease 103(7), p 1780. https://doi.org/10.1094/PDIS-01-19-0070-PDN
Hock J, Dittrich U, Renfro BL, Kranz J (1992) Sequential development of pathogens in the maize tarspot disease complex. Mycopathologia 117(3), 157–161.
Hock J, Kranz J, Renfro BL (1995) Studies on the epidemiology of the tar spot disease complex of maize in Mexico. Plant Pathology 44(3), 490–502.
- CGIAR. Tar spot complex in Latin America. http://maize.org/tar-spot-in-latin-america/ (last accessed 2021-10).
- Corn. IPM-PIPE. Tar spot of corn (Phyllachora maydis). https://corn.ipmpipe.org/tarspot/ (last accessed 2021-10).
Kleczewski NM, Plewa DE, Bissonnette KM, Bowman ND, Byrne JM, LaForest J, Dalla-Lana F, Malvick DK, Mueller DK, MI Chilvers, Paul PA, Raid RN, Robertson AE, Ruhl GE, Smith DL, Telenko DEP (2020) Documenting the establishment, spread, and severity of Phyllachora maydis on corn, in the United States. Journal of Integrated Pest Management 11(1), 1-5. https://doi.org/10.1093/jipm/pmaa012
Malvick DK, Plewa DE, Lara D, Kleczewski NM, Floyd CM, Arenz BE (2020) First report of tar spot of corn caused by Phyllachora maydis in Minnesota. Plant Disease 104(6), p 1865. https://doi.org/10.1094/PDIS-10-19-2167-PDN
Maublanc A (1904) Espèces nouvelles de champignons inférieurs. Bulletin de la Société Mycologique de France 20, 72-74.
McCoy AG, Romberg MK, Zaworski ER, Robertson AE, Phibbs A, Hudelson BD, Smith DL, Beiriger RL, Raid RN, Byrne JM, Chilvers MI (2018) First report of tar spot on corn (Zea mays) caused by Phyllachora maydis in Florida, Iowa, Michigan, and Wisconsin. Plant Disease 102(9), p.1851. https://doi.org/10.1094/PDIS-02-18-0271-PDN
McCoy AG, Roth MG, Shay R, Noel ZA, Jayawardana MA, Longley RW, Bonito G, Chilvers MI (2019) Identification of fungal communities within the tar spot complex of corn in Michigan via Next-Generation Sequencing. Phytobiomes 3(3), 235–243. https://doi.org/10.1094/PBIOMES-03-19-0017-R
Ruhl G, Romberg MK, Bissonnette S, Plewa D, Creswell T, Wise KA (2016) First report of tar spot on corn caused by Phyllachora maydis in the United States. Plant Disease 100(7), 1496-1497. https://10.1094/PDIS-12-15-1506-PDN
Valle-Torres J, Ross TJ, Plewa D, Avellaneda MC, Check J, Chilvers MI, Cruz AP, Dalla Lana F, Groves C, Gongora-Canul C, Henriquez-Dole L, Jamann T, Kleczewski N, Lipps S, Malvick D, McCoy AG, Mueller DS, Paul PA, Puerto C, Schloemer C, Raid RN, Robertson A, Roggenkamp EM, Smith DL, Telenko DEP, Cruz CD (2020) Tar spot: An understudied disease threatening corn production in the Americas. Plant Disease 104(10), 2541-2550.